10 College Essay Mistakes You're Making and How To Avoid Them

Writing your college application essay can feel overwhelming—and for good reason. This single piece of writing serves as your opportunity to show admissions officers who you are beyond grades and test scores. While the stakes are high, many students make preventable mistakes that weaken their essays. Understanding these common pitfalls and how to avoid them can transform your essays from mediocre to memorable.

These pointers are not limited to U.S. Common App personal statements or supplemental essays; they are equally applicable to UC (University of California) applications, UK’s UCAS personal statements, Canadian university essays, and applications to any other geography that requires an essay or personal narrative.

1. Starting Too Late

The Mistake: Many students underestimate how much time a quality college essay requires, often beginning just weeks before their deadline.

Why It's Problematic: Writing a compelling personal statement demands dozens of hours of brainstorming, drafting, and editing. When you start late, you're forced to submit something unfinished and unpolished—hardly the impression you want to make on admissions committees.

How to Fix It: You should begin at least three months before the deadline. This timeline allows for proper brainstorming, multiple drafts, feedback from others, and thorough editing. Remember, you may need to write several essays for different schools, so starting early gives you the flexibility to craft each one thoughtfully.

2. Failing to Understand What Each School Actually Wants

The Mistake: Students often assume all college essays are the same and fail to research specific requirements for each institution.

Why It's Problematic: Each college has unique essay requirements, word limits, and deadlines. Missing these details can result in submitting the wrong essay format or missing supplemental requirements entirely.

How to Fix It: Create a comprehensive chart listing each school's requirements, including word limits, deadlines, and specific prompts. Distinguish between schools that require only a personal statement and those that also want supplemental essays. This organization prevents last-minute scrambling and ensures you address each school's specific needs.

3. Choosing Topics That Don't Matter to You

The Mistake: Students select essay topics they think admissions officers want to hear about rather than subjects genuinely important to them.

Why It's Problematic: If you don't care about your topic, readers won't care either. Essays about topics chosen for their perceived impressiveness often come across as flat and unconvincing. Admissions officers can spot inauthentic writing from miles away.

How to Fix It: Focus on experiences, ideas, or aspects of your identity that genuinely matter to you. Don't feel pressured to write about major life traumas or your biggest achievements—many compelling essays focus on seemingly small moments that reveal something significant about your character. Ask yourself: "What experience or idea has genuinely shaped how I see myself or the world?"

4. Being Too Broad and Generic

The Mistake: Attempting to cover too much ground in your essay, resulting in vague generalizations and surface-level discussion.

Why It's Problematic: With only limited words, you cannot thoroughly explore broad topics like "my family," "sports," or "helping others." These wide-ranging subjects lead to generic statements that could apply to anyone, making your essay forgettable.

How to Fix It: Narrow your focus dramatically. Instead of writing about your entire athletic career, focus on a specific moment during one game that taught you something important. Rather than discussing your love of reading in general, concentrate on how one particular book changed your perspective. Specific anecdotes and focused themes make essays memorable and revealing.

5. Forgetting to Actually Reveal Something About Yourself

The Mistake: Getting so caught up in telling a story that you forget to explain what it means or what it reveals about your character.

Why It's Problematic: The purpose of a personal statement isn't just to recount events—it's to show admissions officers who you are and how you think. Many students write engaging narratives but fail to connect their experiences to personal growth or character traits.

How to Fix It: Before you start writing, clearly identify what aspect of your personality or values you want to highlight. As you write, regularly ask yourself: "What does this show about me?" Don't just describe what happened; explain how the experience affected you, what you learned, and how it reflects your character or shaped your perspective.

6. Rehashing Information Already in Your Application

The Mistake: Using your essay to list achievements, activities, or experiences already covered elsewhere in your application.

Why It's Problematic: Admissions officers have your transcript, activity list, and awards section. Your essay should add new dimensions to your application, not repeat information they already know. Using your personal statement as a glorified resume wastes a valuable opportunity to show different aspects of who you are.

How to Fix It: Choose topics that reveal aspects of your personality not evident in other parts of your application. If you must reference an activity you've listed elsewhere, focus on a specific moment or realization from that experience rather than summarizing your involvement. Your essay should complement your application, not duplicate it.

7. Writing a Boring or Cliché Introduction

The Mistake: Opening your essay with overused phrases, dictionary definitions, or overly general statements that fail to engage readers.

Why It's Problematic: Your introduction creates the first impression of your essay. Admissions officers read thousands of essays—a boring or cliché opening immediately signals that your essay may not be worth their full attention. You have only a few sentences to hook your reader.

How to Fix It: Start with something immediately engaging. Jump into the middle of an interesting moment (in media res), use specific sensory details, or begin with an intriguing statement that makes readers want to know more. Avoid openings like "Ever since I was young..." or "Webster's Dictionary defines..." Instead, drop readers directly into a compelling scene or idea that sets up your larger story.

If you need help choosing the right personal statement for the Common App, check out our detailed guide:

8. Including Too Many Unnecessary Details

The Mistake: Cramming your essay with irrelevant background information or excessive details that don't advance your main point.

Why It's Problematic: Every word in your essay should serve a purpose. Unnecessary details bog down your narrative and prevent you from developing your main themes thoroughly. Readers lose interest when they wade through information that doesn't contribute to understanding who you are.

How to Fix It: Be ruthless in your editing. Every detail should either advance your story or reveal something important about your character. If a sentence doesn't directly support your main theme or help readers understand your perspective, cut it. Focus on vivid, specific details that bring your story to life while serving your larger purpose.

9. Trying to Sound Too Formal or Impressive

The Mistake: Using overly complex vocabulary, formal language, or trying to sound more sophisticated than you naturally are.

Why It's Problematic: Admissions officers want to hear your authentic voice, not an imitation of how you think college students should sound. Overly formal or pretentious language creates distance between you and your readers, making your essay feel artificial and unconvincing.

How to Fix It: Write in your natural voice. Use vocabulary you're comfortable with and sentence structures that feel natural to you. Read your essay aloud—if something sounds awkward when spoken, it probably needs revision. Aim for clarity and authenticity over complexity. Remember, even sophisticated ideas can be expressed in clear, accessible language.

10. Skipping the Editing Process

The Mistake: Submitting your first or second draft without thorough revision, or only checking for basic grammar errors.

Why It's Problematic: First drafts are never your best work. Even talented writers need multiple revisions to craft truly effective essays. Skipping thorough editing means missing opportunities to strengthen your argument, improve your language, and catch errors that might distract from your message.

How to Fix It: Plan for extensive revision. After completing your first draft, set it aside for at least a week before editing. During your first revision pass, focus on big-picture issues: structure, theme, and whether your essay effectively shows who you are. Then get feedback from trusted readers like teachers, parents, or friends. Finally, do detailed proofreading for grammar, word choice, and flow. Read your essay aloud to catch awkward phrasing and ensure it sounds natural.

Moving Forward: Your Path to Essay Success

Avoiding these common mistakes puts you well ahead of many applicants. Remember that writing a strong college essay is a process that requires time, reflection, and multiple revisions. Start early, choose topics that genuinely matter to you, focus your scope, and be authentic in your voice. Most importantly, ensure your essay reveals something meaningful about who you are and what you'll bring to a college community.

Your essays is more than just another application requirement—it's your chance to have a genuine conversation with admissions officers about what makes you unique. By avoiding these pitfalls and approaching your essay thoughtfully, you can create a compelling piece of writing that truly represents your best self and strengthens your entire application.

—--------------------------------------

Amol & Nishant,

The College Crest - Powered by Lets Unbound,

We have worked with thousands of students over the past 7 years. This newsletter captures the essence of our insights to simplify the college readiness journey.